shop by ageBaby & ToddlerLittle KidsBig KidsTweens & TeensFamily & Adult PuzzlesFamily & Adult Games

Staff Favorites

interactive books
feat prod 2
fidgets for stocking stuffersshop for teens and tweens

Welcome to PLAYmatters Toy Shop!

PLAYmatters toy store storefrontVoted Best Toy Store

Come shop the best toy store in Northeast Ohio. We're located at Lander Circle in Pepper Pike. Shop with us for Play Dates, Baby Showers, and Birthday Parties. Stop in, call in your order to 216.464.2424, or order online. Save time with our Curbside Pickup, Parcel Shipping, and complimentary Gift Wrapping.

Wish Lists

Birthdays, baby showers, play dates, and slumber parties are better with great gifts. Now, it's easy to set up a Wish List for your next celebration. It works like any gift registry:

1. Shop. Come shop everything we have in the store. We'll capture your selections. 
2. Share. We'll help you share a link for friends & family. 
3. Wrap. As items are purchased, we'll track them and wrap them. 
Easy, right? To arrange your very own Wish List, visit the shop, call 216.464.2424, or contact us. 

Why Shop with Us?

Your young ones deserve the best. Build a connection with your favorite young people while you enjoy the "shopping local" experience.
  • Complimentary gift wrapping (Pick your paper.)
  • Curated selection of high-quality inventory (No guessing!)
  • Friendly, knowledgable staff (What do those age ranges mean??)
  • Something for every age (Adults, too!)
  • See and feel the products that will delight and engage your young ones